The Thief Knew the Miracle of Forgiveness

My favorite song by Third Day is called “Thief” and is sung from the perspective of one of the two thieves hanging on the crosses next to Jesus. It always brings tears to my eyes. I have seen Third Day in concert five times, and they have played this song every time. I was delighted to find this live version on YouTube:

The exchange between Jesus and the two criminals is recorded in Luke 23:32-43. One of the thieves joins in with the crowd in mocking Jesus. But the other, the one from whose perspective this song is sung, sees Jesus for who He really is.

One of the criminals hanging beside him scoffed, “So you’re the Messiah, are you? Prove it by saving yourself—and us, too, while you’re at it!”

But the other criminal protested, “Don’t you fear God even when you have been sentenced to die? We deserve to die for our crimes, but this man hasn’t done anything wrong.” Then he said, “Jesus, remember me when you come into your Kingdom.” Luke 23:39-42 (NLT).

Two thieves dying next to Jesus. One demands that Jesus save him from the cross, the other asks for mercy. One is stuck in his own conception of what it means to be saved and what he thinks Jesus should do if He was God. The other casts all of his own ideas aside and trusts in Jesus.

I’ve been reading The Day Christ Died by Jim Bishop and came across a passage the other day in the background chapter on Jesus that touches on the different ways in which people viewed, and still do view, Jesus. Some clamor only for grand miracles; others see Him for who He is and trust in His love and mercy for the forgiveness of their sins. Writing about the people’s’ reaction to Jesus’ miracles, Bishop writes:

He dreaded to hear the word miracle. He understood the weaknesses of man—he had promised his Father to give his life in expiation of these weaknesses—but it was an almost horrifying thing to learn that they preferred the working of miracles to being told the road to heaven. They were children, and everywhere he went they grinned and rubbed their hands together and nodded their heads and asked for “a sign.”

They had asked the same thing of John the Baptist and he had had no patience with them. He had roared back that the time of the Messiah was growing shorter and that they had better repent here and now. Signs, he warned them, could come from Satan. But Jesus could not answer in that manner. With all of his heart he loved the people. Their childishness seldom moved him to anger; his response was pity, and more love. Over and over, he would repeat the same lessons to the youthful minds in mature bodies and they would listen, or debate the lessons with him, but, when they warmed to the task of looking fairly upon his face, they would always ask for “a sign.” And, no matter how many times he bowed to their whims, and effected a miracle, they would ask again for “a sign.” Without proof, they would have no part of him. And in grieved him that his chosen twelve needed many miracles too. The Day Christ Died, pg. 105-106.

I love the patience Jesus shows with those who demanded miracles. Even the mocking criminal next to Him on the cross did not anger Him, but this mocker was included in Jesus’ prayer, “Father, forgive them, for they don’t know what they are doing.” Luke 23:34 (NLT). But eventually, those who demand a sign and refuse to see Jesus for who He is lose out on the greatest miracle of all — the forgiveness of sins. The mocking criminal may have been included in His prayer, but He did not say to that criminal, “I assure you, today you will be with me in paradise.” Luke 23:43 (NLT).

Which thief are you more like? Do you want God to just fix everything right now and do things the way you think they should be done? Do you constantly seek more proof, more miracles? Or are you willing to trust that God has a better way? Do you understand that the forgiveness of your sins by our Heavenly Father is greater than any sign or miracle that you could ever see?

I am a Jesus Freak, and I don't care who knows it. I am a wife, mother, sister, aunt, daughter, and friend. My blood family is only part of the larger family of Christ that I belong to. I love to write, especially about my dear Savior.


10 Responses

  1. Hello Linda…

    I am the thief who needed evidence, someone who always wanted a sign. And then He changed me. So it’s not just by faith that I believe, I have proof that everyone who calls on His name will be forgiven and receive a new heart, as promised! The Holy Spirit living in me is all the proof I need!

    Also…I love the song and the video! This sounds like good, contemplative music to drive by and I can’t wait to put it on my iPod. Will you be burning a CD of your favorite hits anytime soon? Sign my up… : )

    • Linda, I agree – the Holy Spirit living in me is all the proof I need, too! So glad you like the song. Third Day is one of my favorite Christian bands. They have a nice mix of mellow praise music and good Southern rock! No plans to burn a CD; I just keep adding stuff to my iPod. 🙂 Peace, Linda

  2. Thanks, Linda

    This is a wonderful post. I’ve been here more times than I can count today. I keep turning your thoughts over and over in my mind and it’s just so much to think on. You’ve packed some really interesting thoughts here in here… Where to start?

    Which thief am I like? I’d say a bit of both… there are days I do “God to just fix everything right now and do things the way (I) think they should be done.” There are other days when I believe I am “willing to trust that God has a better way” . He’s given His promises and I know them to be true…it’s just that some days are more challenging than others. 🙂

    As you said, “thankfully, He knows that I put my trust in Him… He knows where my heart is.

    Blessings and thanks for the hard questions. Trusting Him to lead me through.


    • Ann, It’s nice to hear that after these thoughts are turned over and over in my mind, then finally committed to blog, they take up residence elsewhere. I am so blessed to have this place to share the things that God lays on my heart, and to have fellow bloggers who find them worthwhile to read. Peace, Linda

  3. Oh no . . .I forgot to tell you how much I love that song. It made me cry . . .and how many times have I heard it??? When my oldest was young and taking Tae-kwon-do, I found out her instructor, just a young guy 16 to 17 yrs. old, liked that song. So I gave him my copy of that first cd of theirs. I’m so glad so many of those first songs are still heavy favorites. So easy, for me at least, to see God’s hand upon them. Thank you!!

    • Deb, My favorite part of the song is when he sings, “They nail Him to the rugged cross, and raise Him, they raise Him up next to me.” You can just hear in his voice how unworthy he feels to have the Messiah, the Son of God, next to him. One of my earlierst posts on here was actually about this song, before I knew how to post videos. It’s called The Thief on the Cross. It was also written during Lent, but last year. Peace, Linda

  4. I love the insight you bring to this. Thank you so much. Sometimes in wanting to see those “miracles” I lose sight of the biggest miracle, my salvation and forgiveness of my sins. Only I and He know the extent that my life itself is a miracle, in how He changed me.
    God bless you, Linda, as you continue to lead us on toward Easter with Jesus.

    • Deb, I think I have some idea of the miracle of how He changed you, because He did the same to me, and continues to on a daily basis. 🙂 As humans, I think we are just prone to want to see the other “miracles” and “signs.” I know I was quite touched by Jim’s post about Zahra’s miracle. But I think we have to always keep sight of that most wonderful miracle of forgiveness! Peace, Linda

  5. I love this – I was teaching on the crucifixon to a learning disability group on Sunday, using some basic drama, and as always, learnt quite a few lessons myself! I would love to think that I would be the humble of the sinners, but am also aware that this would probably not be the case. Saying ‘I was wrong, Jesus, and your way is better’ can be a challenge of wills, sometimes, but always worth it. blessings, char48

    • Char, I think that at this point in my life I can safely say I am more like the humble sinner asking for Jesus’ mercy, but that was not always the case and it has been a long journey to get there. Then some days the old me rears its head. Thankfully, He knows that I put my trust in Him. Peace, Linda

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: